Marilyn BauerWriter
Design history · Decorative arts · Civic life

A City Remade

Arthur and Lucia Mathews created a distinctly Californian style—and then put art, craft and design to work rebuilding San Francisco after the earthquake and fire of 1906.

Arthur F. Mathews, Youth
Arthur F. Mathews, Youth, ca. 1917 · Collection of the Oakland Museum of California

At the turn of the last century, movements such as Arts and Crafts and Art Nouveau gained international recognition. Moving from England and Continental Europe to the United States, they influenced everything from architecture to painting to interior design. But on the West Coast of the U.S., there was another sensibility stirring—a regional celebration of classical forms of beauty played out against the sublime landscape of northern California.

Arthur Mathews and Lucia Mathews created the California Decorative Style—an all-encompassing aesthetic featuring golden-hued palettes, striking images of iconic beauty and the portrayal of the romantic possibilities of the area surrounding San Francisco Bay. Classically trained painters with a modernist approach, the couple embraced the idea of “art for art’s sake,” engendering a world of orange California poppies, winged knights atop opalescent steeds and Arcadian maidens dancing amid groves of mighty cypress trees.

Moving beyond the picture plane to the elaborate carving of frames and the embellishment of furniture, ceramics, stained glass, textiles and lamps, the couple became a major force in the early 1900s, while remaining largely unknown outside the state.

Arthur’s easel paintings and murals drew upon classical subjects and mythology imbued with the promise of bountiful lands, productive agriculture, breathtaking vistas and a commitment to the furthering of the arts and sciences. Lucia painted children’s portraits in muted colors with diffused light, as well as landscapes and botanicals; her skill as a carver and decorative artist was renowned in early twentieth-century San Francisco.

Back in California, Arthur resumed teaching while continuing to work on monochromatic pieces. His mural, “The Arts of Peace,” was created as an “endless frieze” for the library of the home of prominent resident Horace Hill. The success of this mural brought Arthur not only recognition but commissions from the social elite.

Then the earthquake and fire changed the scale of their ambition. Beauty was no longer simply something to paint, carve or furnish. It became part of an argument about what a rebuilt city might be.

Art as civic reconstruction

The 1906 earthquake and fire changed the couple’s lives completely. Although Lucia’s studio was saved, many of Arthur’s paintings and murals were lost or destroyed. Determined to employ the arts as a way to fuel the city’s rebuilding, Arthur decided to leave teaching and, along with Lucia, opened the Furniture Shop at 1717 California Street.

The couple believed that imbuing civic surroundings with art and beauty was essential to creating a new San Francisco. They wanted to elevate urban life to the ideal they imagined in their work.

“Arthur felt rebuilding San Francisco was like building a new Athens. He thought it was a utopia.”Curator Harvey L. Jones
Arthur F. Mathews Crusader mural
Arthur F. Mathews, Crusader, created for the former Grand Lodge temple at 25 Van Ness

A civic interior on a monumental scale

Perhaps the couple’s most impressive commission was the interior of the Masonic Temple. Lucia contributed numerous panels, moldings and furniture, including carved and painted doors and gilt-embellished relief panels.

For Arthur, rebuilding offered something larger than replacement. It was an opportunity to rebuild along the lines of Paris and ancient Greece—to bring good art, good architecture and “everything the best had to offer” into the fabric of the city.

A recent investigation of the temple shows how ambitious the commission actually was: the Mathewses’ Furniture Shop was engaged to shape furnishings and decorative elements across the vast interior. Much of the work was later sold, destroyed, covered over or lost. The surviving monumental Crusader mural is now in private storage.

Where painting becomes design

The Mathewses did not treat fine art, furniture and decoration as separate disciplines. Their strongest objects make the boundaries disappear.

Arthur and Lucia Mathews music cabinet

The Furniture Shop—the first artist’s studio to open after the Great Fire—produced highly designed and lavishly decorated furniture and other objects in California Decorative Style. Desks, lathe-turned wooden jars, lamps, bedsteads and tables, all featuring elements of the California landscape, were soon in great demand.

In this music cabinet, image, carving, surface and structure cease to behave as separate arts. The object is simultaneously painting, furniture and interior architecture—the Mathewses’ idea in miniature.

Their achievement was not simply a recognizable style. It was the conviction that art could shape the character of a place—and, after catastrophe, help build that place again.

Music cabinet decorated by Arthur and Lucia Mathews · Two Red Roses Foundation
← Back to Work